Lens 42 of 49 · People and values

Hard choices

When options are equal, who do you choose to be?

Both are good

which person do you want to be?

What is the Hard choices lens?

Ruth Chang’s idea of hard choices says that when two options are on a par, neither better, worse nor equal, more analysis won’t settle it. You make the choice by committing, and in doing so decide who you are. The lens asks which person you want to be.

Where it comes from: Ruth Chang.

The question it asks

If the options are on a par, which person do you choose to be?

What Hard choices shows that a pros-and-cons list misses

Pick a decision and watch what surfaces.

Take the stable bank job or the design studio, both at ₹12 lakh?

What you counted

Both pay the same
Both are in your city

What the lens shows

The bank offers security and a path to manager
The studio offers craft and a smaller company
No list of pros and cons settles it

The fuller question

If the options are on a par, which person do you choose to be?

5 of 5 costs in view

Illustrative examples. The lens doesn’t answer the question; it makes sure you ask the full one.

Works when

  • When two options are close, neither is clearly better, and more analysis won't separate them.
  • Two options are close, and more research won’t separate them
  • You’re waiting for a clear winner that isn’t coming

Misleads when

  • When the options aren't really equal and you haven't looked hard enough.
  • The options aren’t really equal and you haven’t looked hard enough
  • It can be used to skip the work of comparing

In your map

One lens, one of three views

Which job?

Fit with your values

Ask what each would make you

Hard choices

Notice they’re on a par

Regret over time

Commit and set a one-year review

Follows the decision you picked above.

Try it in two minutes

Three steps, in your head or on paper.

  1. 1Check whether one option is better on something that matters, honestly
  2. 2If not, write which person each choice would make you
  3. 3Choose that person, and commit

When reasons run out, commitment is the reason.

Pairs well with

Questions people ask

What is the Hard choices lens?

Ruth Chang’s idea of hard choices says that when two options are on a par, neither better, worse nor equal, more analysis won’t settle it. You make the choice by committing, and in doing so decide who you are. The lens asks which person you want to be.

What question does the Hard choices lens ask?

It asks: “If the options are on a par, which person do you choose to be?” When options are equal, who do you choose to be?

When is the Hard choices lens useful?

When two options are close, neither is clearly better, and more analysis won't separate them.

When can the Hard choices lens mislead you?

When the options aren't really equal and you haven't looked hard enough.

How does Elsewise use the Hard choices lens?

Elsewise picks three lenses that fit your decision, writes a view from each, and shows where those views disagree. Hard choices is one of 49 lenses it can choose from. It maps your thinking; it doesn’t tell you what to do.

What would this lens show you?

Map a decision