Lens 38 of 49 · People and values

Skin in the game

Who pays if this goes wrong?

He earns on the sale

you pay if it falls

What is the Skin in the game lens?

The skin in the game lens asks who carries the consequences if a choice goes badly. Advice, forecasts and pressure from people who share neither your risk nor your costs deserve less weight than from people who do.

Where it comes from: Nassim Nicholas Taleb · Skin in the Game.

The question it asks

Who carries the consequences if this goes wrong?

What Skin in the game shows that a pros-and-cons list misses

Pick a decision and watch what surfaces.

Buy the ULIP your bank manager is recommending?

What you counted

A manager who is very persuasive
Tax benefits on the brochure

What the lens shows

He earns a commission when you sign
He loses nothing if the fund falls
A term plan pays him almost nothing

The fuller question

What does he gain if you buy, and what does he lose if it goes badly?

5 of 5 costs in view

Illustrative examples. The lens doesn’t answer the question; it makes sure you ask the full one.

Works when

  • When advice, responsibility and risk are shared unevenly.
  • Advice, responsibility and risk are shared unevenly
  • A salesperson, advisor or relative is urging you towards something

Misleads when

  • When it assumes everyone can or should bear the same risks.
  • It assumes everyone can or should bear the same risks
  • People with no stake can still give honest, useful advice

In your map

One lens, one of three views

Buy the ULIP?

Incentives

Ask a fee-only planner

Skin in the game

Check who gains

Circle of competence

Buy a plain term plan

Follows the decision you picked above.

Try it in two minutes

Three steps, in your head or on paper.

  1. 1List everyone who is advising you or pushing you
  2. 2Write what each gains or loses if you’re wrong
  3. 3Weigh advice from people who share the downside more heavily

Listen hardest to those who’d lose if you did.

Pairs well with

Questions people ask

What is the Skin in the game lens?

The skin in the game lens asks who carries the consequences if a choice goes badly. Advice, forecasts and pressure from people who share neither your risk nor your costs deserve less weight than from people who do.

What question does the Skin in the game lens ask?

It asks: “Who carries the consequences if this goes wrong?” Who pays if this goes wrong?

When is the Skin in the game lens useful?

When advice, responsibility and risk are shared unevenly.

When can the Skin in the game lens mislead you?

When it assumes everyone can or should bear the same risks.

How does Elsewise use the Skin in the game lens?

Elsewise picks three lenses that fit your decision, writes a view from each, and shows where those views disagree. Skin in the game is one of 49 lenses it can choose from. It maps your thinking; it doesn’t tell you what to do.

What would this lens show you?

Map a decision