Lens 46 of 49 · Question the question

Zero-based thinking

Would you pick this today, starting fresh?

You’re here

because you were here yesterday

What is the Zero-based thinking lens?

The zero-based thinking lens asks: if you weren’t already in this job, place, plan or habit, would you choose it today? Borrowed from zero-based budgeting, it makes you justify what you are keeping instead of only justifying what you might change.

Where it comes from: Zero-based budgeting, applied to decisions.

The question it asks

If you weren't already in this, would you choose it today?

What Zero-based thinking shows that a pros-and-cons list misses

Pick a decision and watch what surfaces.

Stay in the job where you’ve spent five years?

What you counted

Five years of tenure
A manager who knows your work

What the lens shows

If you were offered this job today you’d say no
The commute is 90 minutes each way
The team that made it good has left

The fuller question

If you weren’t already in this, would you choose it today?

5 of 5 costs in view

Illustrative examples. The lens doesn’t answer the question; it makes sure you ask the full one.

Works when

  • When you are staying in a job, place or commitment mostly out of habit.
  • You’re staying somewhere mostly from habit
  • Nothing has been questioned for years because it was already there

Misleads when

  • When starting fresh ignores the real cost of switching.
  • Starting fresh ignores the real cost of switching
  • It treats everything familiar as suspect, including what really works

In your map

One lens, one of three views

Stay in the job?

Sunk cost

Interview elsewhere this month

Zero-based thinking

Ask if you’d take it today

Reversal test

List what you’d actually keep

Follows the decision you picked above.

Try it in two minutes

Three steps, in your head or on paper.

  1. 1Write what you’re currently in and how long it’s been
  2. 2Imagine being offered it today for the first time
  3. 3Say yes or no, then list what you’d need to be true to say yes

What you’d choose from scratch tells you what you want. Switching costs tell you how to get there.

Pairs well with

Questions people ask

What is the Zero-based thinking lens?

The zero-based thinking lens asks: if you weren’t already in this job, place, plan or habit, would you choose it today? Borrowed from zero-based budgeting, it makes you justify what you are keeping instead of only justifying what you might change.

What question does the Zero-based thinking lens ask?

It asks: “If you weren't already in this, would you choose it today?” Would you pick this today, starting fresh?

When is the Zero-based thinking lens useful?

When you are staying in a job, place or commitment mostly out of habit.

When can the Zero-based thinking lens mislead you?

When starting fresh ignores the real cost of switching.

How does Elsewise use the Zero-based thinking lens?

Elsewise picks three lenses that fit your decision, writes a view from each, and shows where those views disagree. Zero-based thinking is one of 49 lenses it can choose from. It maps your thinking; it doesn’t tell you what to do.

What would this lens show you?

Map a decision