Lens 48 of 49 · Question the question
Vanishing options
If neither were possible, what would you do?
Pune or Hyderabad
if neither existed, you’d call your old manager
Two colleges in brochures
a third one was never on the list
Nanny or daycare
a shared nanny sat outside both
What is the Vanishing options lens?
The vanishing options lens asks what you would do if none of your current options were available. Chip and Dan Heath describe how people often weigh two options when more exist. Imagining the first two gone makes you search wider.
Where it comes from: Chip and Dan Heath.
The question it asks
If none of your current options were available, what would you do?
What Vanishing options shows that a pros-and-cons list misses
Pick a decision and watch what surfaces.
Take the ₹18 lakh job in Pune or the ₹20 lakh job in Hyderabad?
What you counted
What the lens shows
The fuller question
If none of your current options were available, what would you do?
Choose between a private college in Pune and a government one in Bhopal?
What you counted
What the lens shows
The fuller question
If none of your current options were available, what would you do?
Hire a nanny or put your toddler in daycare?
What you counted
What the lens shows
The fuller question
If neither option were available, what would you do?
Illustrative examples. The lens doesn’t answer the question; it makes sure you ask the full one.
Works when
- ⇄When you are stuck between two options and haven't looked for a third.
- ◎You’re stuck between two options and haven’t looked for a third
- ◷Both options feel like compromises
Misleads when
- +When the options you invent aren't really available to you.
- !The options you invent aren’t really available to you
- ↺It can send you looking for a perfect third option when one of the two is fine
In your map
One lens, one of three views
Reframe the question
Call your old manager
Vanishing options
Imagine both are gone
Keeping options open
Use the offers to negotiate
Reframe the question
Ask seniors about other colleges
Vanishing options
Imagine both removed
Keeping options open
Check scholarship rules
Reframe the question
Ask neighbours what they do
Vanishing options
Cross out both and think again
Keeping options open
Visit the home creche
Follows the decision you picked above.
Try it in two minutes
Three steps, in your head or on paper.
- 1Write your two options and cross them out
- 2Write what you would do if neither existed
- 3Ask which part of that you could borrow today
The third option often sits in the gap between the first two.
Pairs well with
Questions people ask
What is the Vanishing options lens?
The vanishing options lens asks what you would do if none of your current options were available. Chip and Dan Heath describe how people often weigh two options when more exist. Imagining the first two gone makes you search wider.
What question does the Vanishing options lens ask?
It asks: “If none of your current options were available, what would you do?” If neither were possible, what would you do?
When is the Vanishing options lens useful?
When you are stuck between two options and haven't looked for a third.
When can the Vanishing options lens mislead you?
When the options you invent aren't really available to you.
How does Elsewise use the Vanishing options lens?
Elsewise picks three lenses that fit your decision, writes a view from each, and shows where those views disagree. Vanishing options is one of 49 lenses it can choose from. It maps your thinking; it doesn’t tell you what to do.

