Lens 29 of 49 · Check your own view

Steelman the other side

Build the best case for the side you’re leaning away from.

You’re leaning towards leaving

the best case for staying is about savings and health

What is the Steelman the other side lens?

The steelman lens asks you to state the strongest version of the option you are leaning against, one its own supporters would recognise. It is the opposite of arguing against a weak version, and it shows you what your preferred option has to beat.

Where it comes from: Debate practice.

The question it asks

What is the strongest case for the option you're leaning against?

What Steelman the other side shows that a pros-and-cons list misses

Pick a decision and watch what surfaces.

Leave your parents’ house to rent your own flat?

What you counted

Your parents want you to stay
You think they’re being controlling

What the lens shows

The strongest case for staying: you save ₹30,000 a month
Your father’s health is uncertain
Their case isn’t about control

The fuller question

What is the strongest case for the option you’re leaning against?

5 of 5 costs in view

Illustrative examples. The lens doesn’t answer the question; it makes sure you ask the full one.

Works when

  • When you have half-decided and only hear arguments for it.
  • You’ve half-decided and only hear arguments for it
  • Someone close to you disagrees and you’ve been dismissing their reasons

Misleads when

  • When you steelman an option you have no real interest in and it becomes theatre.
  • You steelman an option you have no real interest in, and it becomes theatre
  • It treats every disagreement as equally strong

In your map

One lens, one of three views

Move out?

Pre-mortem

Write their best argument

Steelman the other side

Make the case for staying

Inversion

Move out in six months, with a plan

Follows the decision you picked above.

Try it in two minutes

Three steps, in your head or on paper.

  1. 1Write the option you’re leaning against
  2. 2Write its best argument, in the words a supporter would use
  3. 3Say what your preferred option would need to beat it

If you can’t state their case, you haven’t earned your own.

Pairs well with

Questions people ask

What is the Steelman the other side lens?

The steelman lens asks you to state the strongest version of the option you are leaning against, one its own supporters would recognise. It is the opposite of arguing against a weak version, and it shows you what your preferred option has to beat.

What question does the Steelman the other side lens ask?

It asks: “What is the strongest case for the option you're leaning against?” Build the best case for the side you’re leaning away from.

When is the Steelman the other side lens useful?

When you have half-decided and only hear arguments for it.

When can the Steelman the other side lens mislead you?

When you steelman an option you have no real interest in and it becomes theatre.

How does Elsewise use the Steelman the other side lens?

Elsewise picks three lenses that fit your decision, writes a view from each, and shows where those views disagree. Steelman the other side is one of 49 lenses it can choose from. It maps your thinking; it doesn’t tell you what to do.

What would this lens show you?

Map a decision