Lens 41 of 49 · People and values

Transformative experience

You can’t know who you’ll be afterwards.

A list written today

is by someone who isn’t yet a parent

What is the Transformative experience lens?

L.A. Paul’s idea of transformative experience points out that some choices, like becoming a parent or moving countries, change who you are as well as what you do. You cannot know in advance what it will be like or what you will want afterwards, so pros and cons lists can mislead.

Where it comes from: L.A. Paul.

The question it asks

Will this change who you are, so you can't know in advance what it will be like?

What Transformative experience shows that a pros-and-cons list misses

Pick a decision and watch what surfaces.

Decide about having a baby by listing pros and cons?

What you counted

Your friends say it’s the best thing
Your savings and flat are ready

What the lens shows

You can’t know what you’ll want once you’re a parent
People describe a change in their priorities that a list can’t predict
The list you write now is written by the person you are today

The fuller question

Will this change who you are, so you can’t know in advance what it will be like?

5 of 5 costs in view

Illustrative examples. The lens doesn’t answer the question; it makes sure you ask the full one.

Works when

  • When becoming a parent, moving countries or a career change will change your own preferences.
  • Becoming a parent, moving countries or a major career change will change what you value
  • You’re trying to predict a feeling you’ve never had

Misleads when

  • When 'unknowable' becomes a reason not to learn from people who have been there.
  • ‘Unknowable’ becomes a reason not to learn from people who’ve been there
  • It makes every big choice sound mystical

In your map

One lens, one of three views

Have a baby?

The outside view

Ask parents what surprised them

Transformative experience

Name what you’re willing to become

Regret over time

Talk to someone who chose differently

Follows the decision you picked above.

Try it in two minutes

Three steps, in your head or on paper.

  1. 1Write what you expect it to feel like
  2. 2Ask three people who’ve done it what surprised them most
  3. 3Decide if you’re willing to become someone who may want different things

Choose the experience, not only the outcome.

Pairs well with

Questions people ask

What is the Transformative experience lens?

L.A. Paul’s idea of transformative experience points out that some choices, like becoming a parent or moving countries, change who you are as well as what you do. You cannot know in advance what it will be like or what you will want afterwards, so pros and cons lists can mislead.

What question does the Transformative experience lens ask?

It asks: “Will this change who you are, so you can't know in advance what it will be like?” You can’t know who you’ll be afterwards.

When is the Transformative experience lens useful?

When becoming a parent, moving countries or a career change will change your own preferences.

When can the Transformative experience lens mislead you?

When 'unknowable' becomes a reason not to learn from people who have been there.

How does Elsewise use the Transformative experience lens?

Elsewise picks three lenses that fit your decision, writes a view from each, and shows where those views disagree. Transformative experience is one of 49 lenses it can choose from. It maps your thinking; it doesn’t tell you what to do.

What would this lens show you?

Map a decision